With lessons from the norse of iron age greenland, deforested easter island and presentday montana, jared diamond talks about the signs that collapse is near, and how. Easter island really does look and feel like an ecocatastrophe. Collapse 2005, the world until yesterday 2012, and upheaval 2019. View homework help discussion questions jared diamond. The ends of the world as we know themjared diamond.
In his article, easter s end, jared diamond makes the following statement, by now the meaning of easter island for us should be chillingly obvious. The pacific ocean, the pitcairn islands, and easter island 8485 the pitcairn islands 122 anasazi sites 142 maya sites 161 the viking expansion 182183 contemporary hispaniola 331 contemporary china 361 contemporary australia 386 political trouble spots of the modern world. How societies choose to fail or survive for the british edition is a 2005 book by academic and popular science author jared diamond, in which the author first defines collapse. Using a vast historical and geographical perspective ranging from easter island and the maya to viking greenland and modern montana, diamond traces a fundamental pattern of environmental catastropheone whose warning signs can be seen in our modern world and that we ignore at our peril. The discovery the island gets its name from its discovery by the dutch explorer jacob roggeveen, on easter april 5 in 1722. Adapted from jared diamond, easter s end, discover, august 1995, 168, pp. Diamond s examination of easter island once again demonstrates that culture cannot survive without nature. Guns, germs, and steel 1997, awarded a pulitzer prize. Diamond believes that the polynesian settlers on rapa nui destroyed its forests, cutting down its trees for fuel and clearing land for 8 answer.
Jared diamond reading is from a chapter in his 2005 book. Island and some other polynesian societies, fertile crescent societies. Central to diamond s easter island ecocide theory is the conclusion that the islanders deforested the island not just for agriculture, but to use the trees to help transport the moai. New information about these themes has recently been flooding in from ongoing projects. Jo anne van tilburg is herself an archeologist who worked long years on easter island. With lessons from the norse of iron age greenland, deforested easter island and presentday montana, jared diamond talks about the signs. Now in a revised edition with a new afterword, jared diamond s collapse uncovers the secret behind. Since then ive gotten to know jared diamond and mark lynas, so i wound up in the middle of their backandforth. Mcanany questioning collapse and jared diamond collapse.
What are the main points of diamonds argument about the. Poor agricultural practices such as massive deforestation are the primary causes of resource depletion. Easter island, with an area of only 64 square miles, is the worlds most isolated scrap of habitable land. Pdf rethinking the fall of easter island terry hunt. In the prologue, jared diamond summarizes his methodology in one paragraph. Lecroy birds of karkar and bagabag islands, new guinea. Twentiethcentury discoveries of pollen prove that rapu nui had once been covered in palm forests, which had turned into grassland by the time the europeans arrived on the island. Collapse 2005 in this book jared diamond tells about the collapse of easter island, but also about several other cases of historical and modern societies who seemingly deliberately destroy the ecosystem.
Environmental trouble spots of the modern world 497. To begin with, the island is the worlds most remote habitable scrap. Tragically, it was statue building that seems to have lead to easter island s collapse. Easter island a society that collapsed entirely due to environmental damage. In the ecocide hypothesis popularised by the geographer jared diamond, rapa nui is used as. Environmental damage, climate change, globalization, rapid population growth, and. In jared diamonds followup to the pulitzerprize winning guns, germs and. How societies choose to fail or succeed titled collapse. How societies choose to fail or succeed, jared diamond argues that the people of easter island are a perfect example of a society whose lack of forethought and resourcegreed led to its demise.
In just a few centuries, the people of easter island wiped out their forest, drove their plants and animals. Diamond, easter island s end, discover magazine, august 1995. Recent archaeological evidence shows the remote islanders didnt commit ecocide. How societies choose to fail or succeed, came out after i finished my degree.
The collapse of easter island by jared diamond this reading is taken from a chapter in diamond s 2005 book. No other site that i have visited made such a ghostly impression on me as did rano raraku, the quarry on easter island where its famous gigantic stone statues were carved. Perhaps there is no one story about easter island, no narrative that fits. Easter island, also known as rapa nui, is an island in the pacific famous for the massive humanoid statues peppered along its coasts. Easter island s end by jared diamond, published in the discover magazine on august 1995, provides insight into how an increased population and rapid deforestation impair the sustainability of the environment. The lessons of easter island western oregon university. Polynesian creators of easter islands famed monumental statueswith what is. In jared diamond s followup to the pulitzerprize winning guns, germs and steel, the author explores how climate change, the population explosion and political discord create the conditions for the collapse of civilization. Easter s end in just a few centuries, the people of easter island wiped out their forest, drove their plants and animals to extinction, and saw their complex society spiral into chaos and cannibalism. Opinion the ends of the world as we know them the new. With lessons from the norse of iron age greenland, deforested easter island and presentday montana, jared diamond talks about the signs that collapse is near, and how if we see it in time.
In just a few centuries, the people of easter island wiped out their forest, drove. Island thesis, in any of its iterations, including diamond s, does not. The article describes the former abundance of trees and forests on easter island. Originally trained in physiology, diamond is known for. Jared mason diamond born september 10, 1937 is an american geographer, historian, anthropologist, and author best known for his popular science books the third chimpanzee 1991. How societies choose to fail or survive is a visionary study of the mysterious downfall of past civilizations.
Opinion the ends of the world as we know them the new york. Among all such vanished civilizations, that of the former polynesian society on easter island remains unsurpassed in mystery and isolation. Get an answer for who has the stronger argument on easter island between patricia a. The easter island ecocide never happened response to. We went there to support it by filling in the missing archeological data. Jared diamond boston massachusetts, 10 september 1937 is een amerikaans. With lessons from the norse of iron age greenland, deforested easter island and presentday montana, jared diamond talks about the signs that collapse is near, and how if we see it in time we can prevent it.
This study guide consists of approximately 62 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of collapse. Easter island, a lesson for us all sustainable footprint. The ends of the world as we know them jared diamond oped article contends that several once powerful societies like mayan and polynesian collapsed because they did not take their environmental. Collapse how societies choose to fail or succeed jared. How societies choose to fail or succeed and from an article in discover magazine. For me, jared s summary about easter island in his 2007 paper in science remains definitive for now. It lies in the pacific ocean more than 2,000 miles west of the nearest continent south america. Pitcairn, the uninhabited island settled in 1790 by the h. Another island, easter island, rapa nui, has 400 stone statues representing a legless human male torso, mostly 15. The easter island ecocide never happened response to jared diamond. From the author of guns, germs and steel, jared diamond s collapse.
Within its pages is a chapter titled twilight at easter. However, the existence of the huge stone statues on the island suggests that the human population on easter was once as high as 17,000. It is a unesco world heritage site, and the majority of the the island is covered by a national park. In just a few centuries, the people of easter island wiped out their forest, drove their plants and animals to extinction. Who has the stronger argument on easter island between. Get an answer for what are the main points of diamond s argument about the easter island societys relationship to its environment, and the outcome.
The mystery stems especially from the islands gigantic stone statues and its impoverished landscape, but it is enhanced by our associations with the specific. In the article jared diamond mentions how the island was already depleted when the first explorers stumbled on its shores and interacted. Such a speculative exercise, given the limited information about. Easter island is a polynesian island located in the pacific ocean. A sustainable society has been falsely blamed for its own demise. Describe several factors that contributed to the extinction of trees on the island. I was there a few years ago and felt devastated by what i saw. Rano raraku is the volcanic quarry on easter island. These moai are commonly called stone heads, but actually most possess bodies, and the largest constructed stands at over 30 feet and weighs 82 tons. Meer dan 27 tweedehands uitgaven beschikbaar vanaf 7,50. The first polynesian colonists found themselves on an island with.
Among all such vanished civilizations that of the former polynesian society on easter island remain unsurpassed in mystery and isolation. This assessment was first put forward in the 1992 book easter island, earth island 4. How societies choose to fail or survive by jared diamond. This study is devoted to answering this one remaining mystery. His technical research focuses on biological membranes, ecology, and evolutionary biology, especially of bird faunas of new guinea and other southwest pacific islands. In jared diamonds followup to the pulitzerprize winning guns, germs and steel, the author. As jared diamond tells it in his bestselling book, collapse, easter island is the clearest example of a society that destroyed itself by. Let us point out that we didnt go to easter island to tear down diamond s thesis. Their movement from quarry to erection site required so many trees for logs and rope making that deforestation was complete by 1400 to 1600 ad. They are linked by diamonds inquiry into what caused some of these societies such as the mayan civilisation or the people of easter island to. Ever since these monoliths were encountered by european explorers in the 18th century, the history of the island. Easter island collapse disputed by hawaii anthropologist.
1042 1157 1174 1632 1289 78 390 973 70 993 927 1165 1440 1157 916 842 570 174 993 62 894 1046 1418 1459 159 1471 1037 1339 1406 216 660 968